05 February 2006 @ 02:13 pm
Stargate SG-1, SGA, and Battlestar Galactica  
Stargate started off the night with, "Ethon." On balance, it left me very, very happy. Random memories...

- I'm with just about every other fan I've read, Michael Shanks was back in character; the Daniel whom so many of us fell in love with was in the house. Huge, relieved fangirl squee. I love the Daniel who doesn't give up on people, even when he thinks they've killed his team. Although, Daniel is sure sounding Canadian these days. That accent is creeping through more and more for him and for Amanda Tapping, though hers is less egregious. I suppose I'll have to fanwank it as the accent Daniel acquired when he was passing for Canadian while backpacking through Europe as a young college lad.

- Speaking of that, I wibbled when Daniel was in the jail after the Prometheus was destroyed. Damn, it's such a pleasure when Daniel is present. But can I say that I soooooo do not appreciate this crap about yet another inappropriate relationship? Sam and Jack (I know, a couple people here will disagree) was inappropriate and Daniel and Leda-the-Married-Woman was inappropriate. That scene wouldn't have bugged me if Daniel had reached out in sympathy, to comfort the widower instead of shrinking in on himself. Grrrrrr. Since the writers' idea of romance really bugs me, I wish they'd just not write it.

- Yay for team! Woot! The reunion amongst Sam, Teal'c, and Cameron was exactly the sort of stuff that makes me happy. *sniffle* Excellent, excellent.

- I think by now my love of slash has been established, though my dirty secret is that with very rare instances, I haven't ever seen the Jack/Daniel subtext. But even I am being hit over the head with the Cameron/Teal'c sparkage. Not that I want anything on screen - see my previous bitchery about writers not writing what I consider satisfying romance - and frankly I like it left for the viewers to interpret. But that Cameron has got the fanboy man-crush thing going on Teal'c. ;-)

- Strangely cute way for them to wrap it up, with Daniel eyeing the can of Coors with a head-tilt mannerism remininscent of my very cute dog. Having seen Michael suck down the beers in rapid succession, I know that was acting. ;-) Seriously, though, weird juxtaposition of his body language and the topic under discussion. Very dark, very realistic.

- In no way sorry to see the Prometheus blown up. I don't like abandoning the Stargate for the stupid ships. I was, however, very sad to see the captain die. They finally figured out a way to film someone's death in a way that touched me, though I really wish they'd quit the character slaughter they've been on since Season 5.

- Minor quibbles: Couldn't they at least have stuck in a, "General Landry gave us the go" line? It's really weird for a team to just decide to go on a mission. I'd really have preferred to see Carter as the Cassandra here. "But these plans don't indicate power source and we know it's coming from the Orii...maybe we should be a little cautious?" and then getting overruled by an overzealous military member. SOMETHING to show that Sam has learned to be a little more cautious? Then again, maybe not; one of her endearing qualities is her self-assuredness. Um, if the first shot goes right through your shields and your engines won't let you retreat, maybe maneuvering around instead of sitting in one place would defeat the satellite's targeting system? At least try it? If you have Asgard beams, why not beam the satellite itself out of the control range of the planet? At least try it? There were lots of options that even I, totally at sea in all things military, can think of that weren't tried. I don't mind that they take some shortcuts, but I'd like our highly competent military teams at least look like they are.

~~**~~

-Very short notes on Stargate Atlantis (haven't a clue what the episode name was). I'm not generally a fan and I thought the plot entirely too predictable. Read above bitchery about the writers' way of writing romance/sex and my views. *yawn*

- Peter Woodward!!!! Loved him in Crusade. Love the weapons and fighting show he has done for the history channel. Has a mesmerizing voice and I didn't give three figs that most everything else around him, down to the obvious budget-conscious "duplicate city," was just stupid and annoying.

- The only other thing that wasn't annoying? HARLAN!!!! er, the King. :) I sooooo wanted to hear him ask Carson if he was there to make him, better.

- ETA: Oh yeah, should I bitch about the fact that only men have this ancient gene, thus far, or should we just take it as I thoroughly snarked about this stupidity with its cliché "princess must shag John to produce progeny with a 'strong' Ancient gene to save herself from a forced marriage worse than death" storyline *barf* *barf again* *barf a third time* and not torture anyone with my extreme annoyance?

- The writers' complete ignorance on all things biological has always made this show impossible for me to enjoy. I sure hope the SGC has shared this new form of 'gene therapy' with leukemia and sickle cell anemia patients. Especially seeing as it's so rapid and painless and all. *sigh*

~~**~~

Battlestar Galactica was back in fine form. Last week's episode left me wondering if the Stargate writers had wandered into the wrong offices and left a romance script there. Blech.

Anyhow, we now learn that Starbuck is also battling suicidal tendencies. Struck me as annoying at first - after all, Apollo has got that topic covered and couldn't we come up with some different problems to explore? - but on giving it thought...it would be a HUGE problem for people stuck in space, running from the "toasters" who just blew up most everyone they ever knew. So, um, yeah, depression and substance abuse in more than one lead seems realistic.

I kinda wish I'd seen the alcohol, the angst, and the depression coming with Starbuck but I won't know how truly it is out of left field until I get the DVDs and sit down and watch them in rapid succession. Not so impressed with her falling into alcohol abuse seeing as she was riding Tighe for the self-same problem. Pot, meet kettle.

Cat is developing into a character and I find I like her - and hate her. She's wrong to undermine Starbuck's authority at every turn but then she's not actually wrong in her accusations. I hate seeing her kick Starbuck when she's down but it's not as if handling Starbuck with kid gloves would be effective.

A lot of fans are happy over the Starbuck/Apollo almost-sex. I liked it for Apollo's insight into Starbuck's ability to deal with live men - and it had some real heat, the two have chemistry - but I'd rather pull back from their conflagration. I find a little dose does me, really. I liked them more together when they're buddies, watching each others' backs. Besides, too many "almosts" and it gets annoying and coy.

The Starbuck / Sharon scene could well be my favorite. It's fascinating to ponder a shifting emotional landscape in which your best friend turns out to be the enemy. I still haven't figured out the individual Cylon motivations but I watch in fascination each week, hoping to fogure them out. Lots of good angst potential and they know how to use it. The guards' reaction to Sharon reaching for Starbuck ripped my heart out. Beautiful, beautiful stuff.

No real Adama, Roselin, Baltar, or Six this week. And I didn't even notice until it was all over.

I know I've missed the more referential, allegorical aspects of the show - I don't seem to get those on the first watching. It's the sort of thing I have to let simmer in my brain and stew before I decide what it means to me re. everyday life and the current geopolitical landscape. For now, it's all surface.
Tags: ,
 
 
Current Mood: contemplative
 
 
( Post a new comment )
[identity profile] ciaracat.livejournal.com on February 6th, 2006 01:28 am (UTC)
I just started watching Sci-Fi Friday again last week, for the first time in.. hm.. 2 years? 3? I'd caught myself up on Battlestar Galactica through Netflix and the library and BitTorrent. Stargate SG-1 I haven't seen in years. Stargate Atlantis was just starting up right after I lost cable however long ago that was, so I'd never seen that at all.

So, that being said. :)

Agreed about the way they write romances on Stargate. *rolls eyes*

On Stargate this week, I was under the impression that they'd lost power to do pretty much anything with that first shot that hit them? They were babbling a lot about trying to get the sub-light engines up, and I kindof had the impression that it was only Sam's mucking about that let them beam people to the planet. Not sure.

I also have to comment on how badly it's messing with my mind to have JOHN on friggin' STARGATE as a main character! I'm like "No! Wrong show! Wrong show!" Sorry. Personal problem. I'll get over it. :D

And I completely agree with the science problems with Stargate Atlantis! My mom and I were laughing our butts off watching it, and my sister and I enjoyed poking fun at it the week before too. "Here's a vial of gene therapy for you. No instructions. Go to it."

Good points about Battlestar -- depression and substance abuse would be pretty rampant at this point, wouldn't it? I was in the same place you were.. Was wondering at this sudden-seeming plummet into alcoholism that Starbuck seemed to develop since last week. Would have liked to see more lead-in into it, like you say. I think the angst was already very much there. And her emotional stability has been deteriorating.. Not only the guy she left behind on Caprica.. The whole playout of the thing with the Pegasus' commander (before she died) was taking a huge toll on her as well. But the alcoholism.. the more I think about it, the more sense it makes. And the fact that she was always riding Tighe makes sense too.. People with the tendency to be addicts tend to be the ones to really ride someone about their addiction like that.. I mean, the one riding Starbuck is a stim junkie. Wonder if seeing Cat with her Top Shooter Spot will give her the kick in the ass that she needs.

I was explaining stuff to my mom during the Sharon scene.. I may have to download it so I can watch that again.

Sorry for the long rambling. I'd better get back to work.

Please keep posting these. I really enjoyed reading it.
Mish: BSG Graces[identity profile] hsapiens.livejournal.com on February 6th, 2006 04:47 am (UTC)
Part 1 of 2
Wow. Thank you for the nice compiment. I almost didn't make this public because it's really more my impressions. Most of my flisters from the fandoms manage to get their impressions online the same night it all airs and by the time I'm done thinking about it, they're onto the next topic. :)

I normally torment poor [livejournal.com profile] jalabert with all of my carping and she keeps telling me, "it's only tv" and I keep going, "but...but..." so I've been recording my thoughts just for myself. Glad someone else enjoys picking it apart, even if it's late. Welcome back to Sci Fi. As much as I complain, I'd be bereft without my Friday nights.

On Stargate this week, I was under the impression that they'd lost power to do pretty much anything with that first shot that hit them? They were babbling a lot about trying to get the sub-light engines up,

I'll have to go back and rewatch it because I knew they couldn't jump out of the way but I thought Sam attributed their indecision both in firing immediately and then pausing afterwards instead of moving as mistakes. But I'll have to listen for what she says in more detail; I'm prone to remembering it to support my opinions. (And, yanno, I'm so proud of the writers to have noticed it was a mistake.) In any case, the venting of the atmosphere *should* have caused the ship to move so I'm still not convinced they put enough thought into the scene. The outcome could have been the same, but I'd like to see the military people run through some options before giving up.

If we had to lose Richard Dean Anderson, and I'm one those who were quietly relieved he left since he'd long ago lost all interest in playing the character as I'd learned to love him, I'm very glad they got Ben Browder. I'm not overly familiar with him but what I've seen here and on Farscape impresses me and everything I've heard (admittedly from his fans) indicates he's an excellent person in real life. Given the circumstances, and the assurance I would never have the irreverent but nonetheless effective Jack O'Neill back as SG-1 leader, I can be happy to watch Cameron. Already, he's shown a nice bit of leg so the totally shallow part of me is happy, too. Ben will never have to answer the dreaded, "boxers or briefs?" question at cons.

I won't go any further on the whole SGA debacle. At this point, it's willful ignorance and it makes me froth.

Oh - I have no problem with seeing Kara has a dark side. It's just that I've seen her control it so much better. Something seems to have made her crack and I'm curious as to what it is. (Knowing that Lee is suicidal? Raging hormones from being impregnated by the Cylons? Raging hormones from being impregnated by Anders? Loss of control because her drinking lowers her ability? Losing one more pilot was the proverbial straw on the camel's back?)

I'm still dying to know the fallout from her time in Cylon hands and I can't help but think that this much alcohol could cause spontaneous abortion if they were up to what I have presumed. Yeah, she seemed to bond with Anders but...we haven't seen torment or regret or even stopping to reflect or feel a little down...it's not that I must be spoon-fed but I'd like to have had some inkling of her feelings before melt-down. *shrug* It's really a relatively minor complaint. They've certainly given me enough causes to fill in the blank.
Mish: BSG Graces[identity profile] hsapiens.livejournal.com on February 6th, 2006 04:47 am (UTC)
Part 2 of 2
I find I hate Cat for how she's treating Starbuck but then...she's also shown that she has excellent people skills. I can't help but wonder how much of her attitude is her and how much is knowing which buttons to push while trying to get Starbuck to snap to reality. I love that I don't really know; the ambiguity means I have to keep my mind open to possibilities and reserve judgment. I like the ambiguity. Nothing here is entirely balck and white - except that the Cylons are out to eradicate humanity. Except not. They're fascinated by us; they've recreated themselves in our image; they're trying to become us. They want to be alive.

It's really quite a lot to chew on each week. Absolutely my favorite sci-fi show since Babylon 5. I don't just love it for the gorgeous Jamie Bamber or for the strong and interesting women or for having actors who don't all look either air-brushed or permanently surprised or for the strong writing -- I love for all those reasons and because I find new aspects on every re-watch and new things to think about.