After replying to your comment in my LJ, I realized that I never replied to this comment. I wouldn't say that I "don't like" BSG. I just never got into it. I suppose mostly because for a time I was afraid to commit to many new shows because I did not have time to keep up with them while I was finishing school (accelerated program while working full-time - insanity at its finest)...and graduating with a 3.99. *brags a little and provides clue about OCD tendencies* I don't think I watched anything on television except Stargate for those two whole years - and most of Stargate was caught up on through the DVDs. Anyway, it's quite clear to me that you are very sharp. Your writing and insight into things is quite impressive. As for me, I think I have a tendency to be somewhat less critical of television shows that I watch. When I compare earlier SG1 to newer SG1, yes, the quality is definitely not the same. At the same time, though, I just get caught up in enjoying watching SG-1 and Atlantis because I enjoy the Stargate concept and the actors. I think my major disappointment occurred with the 200th episode - it just didn't do it for me - and that is probably one of the first times I can say that an episode was really exceptionally disappointing.

Is there anything wrong with your critical eye? Absolutely not. I have an incredible tendency to be very critical of live theatre since I used to do so much of it. I guess just not so much with television - I must just be getting lazy!